I agreeto Idea Specify Open Standards

36 votes

I disagreeto Idea Specify Open Standards

Rank1

Idea#15

This idea is active.
Common Data, Services and Applications »

Specify Open Standards

The Roadmap for the Geospatial Platform states it “will be established as a service-oriented architecture based upon common, secure, interoperable and scalable open-standards based technologies.” The Roadmap also says that through the FGDC, standards that shall be evaluated for adoption by the Federal Government include: Geospatial data publication standards from the Open Geospatial Consortium (OGC), the International Organization of Standardization (ISO), the International Committee for Information Technology Standards (INCITS) L1 committee, and the FGDC including but not limited to the Web Services (features, map, processing, coverage, etc.).

This is a laudable objective and will provide increased transparency and collaboration capability for the Geospatial Platform. However, the Government should consider specifying which standards are to be implemented on a “sooner rather than later” basis. Advance guidance to the US technology community will help it better understand where potential investment, development and implementation may be needed. In addition, guidance on open-standards based technologies should clearly state that client applications and ingestion technology, as well as services and data, must implement the specified open-standards to participate in the geospatial platform. This will avoid interoperability problems, defacto stovepipes and lack of usability.

Comment

Submitted by Jeff Harrison 2 years ago

Vote Activity Show

(latest 20 votes)

Comments (3)

  1. In the spirit of transparency, the geodata services and capabilities offered by the Geospatial Platform should be built to be accessible in a vendor-neutral, platform-independent manner - open, standards-based solutions such as OGC, W3C, IETF along with ATOM and OpenSearch.

    2 years ago
  2. then there are the 800 lb gorillas with their "standards" for web services. In a virtual instant they reshaped the web serices standards forces states, local and tribal data/web service efforts to re-create services or manage multiple versions for national versus state/local needs.

    2 years ago
  3. I agree with the idea of Open Standards so that the interoperability of the products have a common basis, but disagree with having the Government decide which standards are to be implemented. In the interest of all, the government should follow market leads and not try to steer it. That way bad ideas will get weeded out more quickly, and tax payer dollars aren't wasted on standards that were not thought out fully or market tested first to see if they are even viable.

    2 years ago